Cart 0
 
 
 

EVERYONE LOVES PIE.

 

 

Proper_Pie_Richmond_Caroline_Martin_Photography01_e1e6f643-8fae-4353-a270-fb5c94a6965c.jpg
 
 

Be a hero.
Order pie for the whole gang!

 

We would love to prepare an order of savory and sweet pies for your next event! It’s nearly as easy as eating pie. A few quick tips for planning and ordering ahead:

  1. Determine how many savory pies and sweet pies you’d like to order.

    Savory pies are individual, handheld size. We recommend one per person. Sweet pies are standard, whole pies. Typically we recommend 1 sweet pie for 8 people.

  2. determine how many of each type of savory pies you’d like to order.

    Savory pies come in beef, chicken, pork, fish or lamb, vegetarian, vegan, rolls and pastries. You can choose the type, but specific flavors within each type change daily. Read our FAQ if you have additional questions.

  3. place your order request using our online form at least 24 hours in advance (1 week ahead for larger orders).

    Orders for more than 20 savory pies or 4 sweet pies require one week’s notice. This ensures we have all of the freshest ingredients on hand for your order!

  4. be on the lookout for a confirmation email or call.

    Someone from our team will give you a call or email to confirm the order, take payment, and clear up any remaining details. For larger orders of savory pies or more than 4 whole sweet pies, we will require a 50% deposit. However, some folks opt to pay the entirely in advance, but that’s up to you!

Finally, if you’re interested in holiday orders, please keep scrolling. Details on holiday ordering dates are at the bottom of this page!

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Pie Order Request Form

 
Name *
Name
Phone Number *
Phone Number
Would you like savory pies? *
Minimum of 8, maximum of 100.
Please specify your desired savory protein category. For example, 6 chicken, 2 beef, 2 vegan. CATEGORIES: chicken, beef, pork, fish, lamb, vegetarian, and vegan.
Would you like to order sweet pies? *
NOTE: We do our best to fulfill your sweet pie order dreams, but sometimes specific ingredients are not available. We will confirm with you what's available before we finalize your order. Our typical flavors include: Apple, Banoffee, Banana Cream, Blueberry Apple (vegan), Buttermilk & Raspberry, Chocolate Chess, Chocolate Raspberry Cream, Coconut Cream, Coconut Key Lime "Meringue" (vegan), Lemon Meringue, Mango Coconut Custard, Meyer Lemon Ginger & Blackberry (vegan), Mixed Berry Streusel, Pear & Almond Tart, Pecan, Sour Cream & Wild Blueberry, Strawberry Cream, Strawberry Rhubarb (vegan)
What date would you like to pick up your pies? *
What date would you like to pick up your pies?
*We need at least 3 days notice for large orders.
What time would you like to pick up your pies? *
We do our best to accommodate your specific order requests, but our ingredients and flavors change daily so please consider this when you place an order request!
 
 
new-green-Artboard 60@4x.png
 

HOLIDAY PIES!

 
 

Important Details

Twice a year we open our online shop for holiday pie orders. Due to extremely high demand, each order is limited per person and quantities sell out quickly. Bookmark these dates and get on our email list so you don’t miss out on these epic holiday treats!

 
 
 

Save these dates!

Thanksgiving orders → Start october 1

holiday orders → start november 31

 
 
teal-piesArtboard 83@4x.png
 
 

Never miss out on an opportunity for pie:

Our emails are few and far between, but when we send them, you better believe it’s good. Get on our email list to make sure you never miss out an opportunity to order holiday pies again!